Written October 17, 1988
I was out in the back yard shooting baskets with some of the boys from the neighborhood. It was a crisp, sunny fall afternoon, sweatshirt weather, and I was feeling great about life. I had finally gotten the knack of the jump shot, and was really proud of myself.
The back door open, my Dad called out, “Son, come here a minute.”
I walked over to him, breathing hard from the exertion.
“Get your jacket, we’re going down to the Y.”
“The Y? How come?”
“I’ve signed you up for boxing lessons,” he said, in that tone like when it was time for me to get a haircut; no more talk, this is just the way it is, just do it!”
So I said nothing and went along, puzzled. I was 11, in the 5th grade, but I hadn’t been in trouble or getting in fights or anything. But boxing was important to my Dad, I knew that. A ritual at our house was to watch the Gillette Friday Night at the Fights. Dad had boxed in the Marine Corps while he was stationed in Hawaii. But I had never particularly gotten off to the idea of getting hit; volunteering for it seemed especially bizarre.
So I started taking boxing lessons at the local YMCA. Twice a week, after school, my Dad would drive me down and hang around watching me for an hour, while I went through a rudimentary boxing workout – sparring, heavy bag, and a little, very little, coaching. It only confirmed that I didn’t like being hit, so one day in the car, I asked him about it.
“Dad,” I asked, “why am I doing this boxing stuff, you know, taking these lessons and all?”
He looked awkward and embarrassed, the way he did when talking about anything more personal than the World Series. “Son, knowing how to defend yourself is something a man needs to know. I thought it was time you learned it, and that this was the best way to do it.” He patted me clumsily on the shoulder.
I sensed that fighting was the proving ground – the entrance test to manhood. But from what I saw of the kids at school who fought a lot, if you won, the good feeling lasted a minute, if you lost, the defeat burned deep. It looked like a neverending test.
After about two months of lessons I found out that Dad had entered me in Fight Night – an amateur fight card held one Friday night a month at the YMCA. I knew there was no way in hell I wanted to do that. When he told me, my mouth fell open, my eyes widened, and I started to say something. I looked at him and saw the determined set of his jaw and the knitted brow – his “because I say so” look. So I said nothing.
————–
Friday afternoon. The afternoon of Fight Night. My mouth was so dry I couldn’t swallow – somehow it had just become real that I was going to go through with it. Dad brought home my equipment – bright red trunks, baggy on my skinny frame, a red silk T-shirt, mouthpiece, and a jock strap. It was my first experience of a jock strap, and it increased my dread – if you needed to protect yourself “down there,” the whole business took on a deadly air.
I don’t even remember driving to the Y. The first thing I remember was sitting in the locker room – mingled smells of sweat, analgesic, and an aura of fear. I could hardly look at the other boys sitting around on benches, each of us in similar gear. The shiny new red boxing gloves I wore looked huge and ominous as I stared down at them.
I could hear the murmur of the crowd outside, periodic bells, clapping and cheering. My Dad was not around, but I knew he was out there, in the crowd, watching. I had never been to Fight Night; I had no idea what to expect.
It came my turn; I felt numb. I walked out of the locker room. The gym was darkened, except for the bright band of yellow, musty light shining down from the ceiling on to the ring. The ring was fenced with ropes, elevated, separated from the crowd.
I walked mechanically down the long darkened aisle, the crowd a looming yet physical presence on either side of me. I climbed up the steps, ducked through the ropes and into the ring. My opponent stood shaking his arms in the blue corner, but I could not meet his eyes.
I felt exposed, vulnerable. I could see no one outside the circle of light, but heard the rumble, could feel the people, most of all could sense my Father, expectant.
We were to fight 3 two minute rounds. The referee called us to the center of the ring, and we stood, two young boys, one in red, one in blue, facing each other – and the test. We touched gloves and went back to our corners.
The bell rang and I moved slowly toward him. He lunged at me and began hitting me in the face and stomach. I stood numbly and took it, hardly throwing punches, forgetting all I’d learned, too scared to move, hating the pain, feeling the hurt. It felt interminable, yet suddenly a bell rang and I was on a stool in the corner. I wiped my nose on my glove and horrified, saw a dark smear of blood.
The bell rang and it started again. I began crying; I just wanted it to stop. Suddenly the hitting stopped and I became dimly aware that I was standing alone under the bright lights, crying. The referee was holding up the other boy’s arm. He had won. I was a loser twice over, for losing the fight, and for crying. I had failed the test.
I cried and cried, I could not stop. Someone wiped my nose on a white towel and it came away red. I staggered back out of the ring and started the endless walk back down the darkened aisle, my head hanging, sniffing and sobbing. My Dad was not around – part of me was glad; part of my soul silently cried out for him. I wanted to run, to hide; to hide from my Dad, to hide from my shame.











The things we are put through as children – the tests that are really not about us at all, but about the failures and self-perceived shortcomings of our parents – are probably the deepest wounds we carry.
For me, my father’s “thing” was education and knowledge. My tests were usually about history, since that is what he taught. When I was eight, over summer “vacation” from school, my father presented me with a blank map of Europe. Over the next few weeks he would write the names of the countries in the spaces and tell me about them. Each week I was given a fresh, blank map and left alone to fill in all the countries.
It was a month before I was able to mark them all. The bigger ones – England, France, Germany, Itally – those I got failry quckly. The ones I had never heard of – luxemburg, Andora, Monaco – those took longer.
When I finally complete the map I ran to tell him. He immediately handed me a map of the U.S.
When I looked hurt at his lack of enthusiasm, his remark was “you don’t even know your own country?”
And so I began to learn all the states.
With my father each test was completed, in time, but was always met with a harder challenge and belittlement at how little I knew. Eventually I gave up on his tests. I stopped trying. I learned to dissociate when he grew angry and impatient at my lack of interest. Part of me knew, even then, that there was no pleasing him, that I would never gain his approval.
It is a lesson I am still learning… part of me has held onto hope. It’s only this year that I have finally come to realize that it is completely hopeless. I am planning a “ceremony” to help me process this “letting go”. I’m hoping a ritual of some kind will help me grow in my understanding of this and will commemorate a transition that is perminant, final and complete.
PS
I was completely enthralled with your telling… to the point of being driven to tell something of my story. I hope you don’t mind.
Shen – Oh, I totally don’t mind if you were driven to tell something of your story after reading my post! Your strong reaction just tells me that the writing worked! I was delighted to see you use the word “enthralled” in how you reacted to reading it! That’s strong praise, and I appreciate it!
And of course, there was what you shared – I heard so much that was just what I had experienced in the fight experience! I was essentially set up to fail – and then I got stuck with ownership of the failure. And for you – successfully learning all the countries of Europe, and instead of praise, being belittled for meeting a goal that hadn’t even been set yet! I can completely understand why you would give up on the tests, and even disassociate through the anger and impatience! And realizing that there was no pleasing him. But for the child – perfectly natural to feel we had failed, when the parent failed us!
I love your direction of a “letting go” ritual. I know those have been extremely powerful and significant for me! It’s as if when I’m ready to do a ritual, I’m accepting the letting go at a more real level, and it’s time to move on! I would love to hear about your ceremony when you do it, if you’re comfortable with that! It usually takes me a while to talk about those – they have to be private until I fully assimilate them! But whenever, I’d love to hear more!
Thank you so much for your wonderful response!
Dan
“Feel wehad failed when the parent failed us”
Very wise words. That is exactly it.
I will be writing about the ceremony when its all done… I’m not sure when that will be. It feels big, and it will take me time to do it “right”.l
Do you have writing about your letting go rituals? I am researching others’ experiences with something like this… would love to read yours.
Shen -
Yes, taking on the blame for failing when we were set up to fail is an astonishing transaction! But I’ve heard it so many times in meetings of adults who survived an alcoholic family that I no longer feel alone!
I love your direction to take your time with the ceremony, and “do it right.” Letting go rituals – one is on this blog, and called “A Conversation With Dad.” I wrote the piece, and then later I went to Tulsa and read it out at his land, as a way to let go. I have those notes and plan to write them up formally when the time feels right. Another one is “Independence Day – Little Danny Set Free,” which you’ve read. It is one of the most powerful rituals I’ve ever done. Then, in my book “Freedom’s Just Another Word,” I have a number of rituals. One in particular comes to mind where I took a lot of pieces of paper, wrote on each of them one of the ways I had changed. I reflected over them, then I burned them. All of those experiences are where you can read about them.
Other rituals I haven’t written up yet: One time I even did a sweat lodge with an Indian wise man to release parts of me I was letting go! Major amazing! I took a book I had written, not yet published, entitled “Nothing Left to Lose,” and since I wanted to release it to the universe and not have it be about me, I took a copy to northwest New Mexico and burned it! I’ll be writing about that in my next book. Ritual has been a big part of my recovery. One of my friends, who has shared in the journey, even did his doctoral dissertation on “The Impact of Ritual in the Educational System.” Wow – you really got me to reflecting, but that’s a great way to see parts of my journey for what they are.
The thing I have learned about rituals is that they sort of tell me when the time is right, and when I’m supposed to do them. Too soon, and they feel forced. OK not to know when it will be, and yes, it feels like it will be really big! WOW!
Dan
I loved your story. I can appreciate how difficult it was for you to share it with the world. Thank you so much for your courageous heart. I am really pleased that you are taking steps to heal all the wounds from your childhood rather than pass them along to an unsuspecting wife, child, or friend. It is a process and one that takes far too long. Congratulations on your progress so far. Keep up the good work and especially the sharing as we all learn something valuable from another’s discoveries. God bless you. ros.
Ros -
Thank you so much for what you shared! I’m glad you appreciated that story, and what it took for me to put it out there! I’ve done a lot of recovery work to get past the effects of my childhood, and it is humbling to see that work honored! I made a decision years ago that “it stops here,” and that has given me the impetus to keep going. An amazing piece of my story is the healing my Dad and I got after he sobered up, and how he illuminated my path to healing by his example of perseverance in overcoming his own demons! I am very blessed!
Warmly,
Dan
Found my way over to the new blog. Like the new look!
Why thank you! I’ve been pleased – WordPress has lots of things that I wanted, and I’ve been very happy with the change!
Dan
What a terrible situation to be in… The only experience I have with fighting was in 5th grade (same as you), I had a boy bully me in school. I hung around with older kids (sorta rough) and they encouraged me to challenge him to a fight. I did. I kicked the snot out of him. That was one of the better days of my life.
Goes to show, that two similar situations could have dramatically different impact on a 5th grader…
Yes, this was a pretty awful situation, for sure! I had never been in any kind of a fight before then, so why we were doing this was never clear.
In 8th grade, I had something like you said – an older kid wanted me to fight a guy. We both walked away. Saw him at a 40th reunion, he didn’t even remember it!
Glad your situation turned out in your favor, and yes, amazing how things turned out so differently!
Thanks for letting me know that Paul!
Dan
This a lovely piece of writing about a very unlovely experience, dan. Thanks for putting it up.
Thank you for taking the time to visit my site, and for your very kind comments! Yes, it was a very unfortunate experience! But talking about it is part of moving past it!
Dan
Our abusive parents find all kinds of ways to pass their shame onto us as helpless children.
[...] thought maybe it was a fluke until it happened a second time, on a piece I had written entitled “Fight Night,” about my Dad introducing me to boxing. The teacher took about 40 minutes to go through that [...]